Loading...
Loading...
Value & Proposition
Two sides of the same coin: what a member is worth to you, and the value they get for their dues. How to measure and strengthen both.
Two Sides
Membership value means two things at once, and a healthy organisation manages both.
The first is the value of a member to you — their lifetime value, the total they generate across the years they stay. The second is the value a member receives for their dues — the benefits, access and outcomes that make membership worth paying for.
These two are linked. Members who feel they get real value stay longer, which raises their lifetime value; members who do not, lapse. Get the proposition right and the economics follow.
84%
Median renewal rate — a retained member compounds in value (MGI 2025)
~6 yrs
Average tenure at the 84% median renewal rate
11%
Of associations call their value proposition ‘very compelling’ (MGI 2025)
Side One
Measuring membership value as lifetime value.
The value of a member is roughly their annual value multiplied by how long they stay. Tenure is the inverse of churn, so at the sector median 84% renewal rate the average member stays about six years — and even modest dues add up to a lifetime value many times the cost of acquiring them. Harvard Business Review puts acquisition at five to 25 times the cost of retention, which is why lifetime value, not the joining fee, is the number that matters.
Put your own figures in the free membership lifetime value calculator, then see how retention moves the number with the membership retention calculator.
Side Two
A proposition worth paying for, communicated all year.
Identify the benefits that genuinely drive joining and renewal, and lead with them.
Positioning
Content and thought leadership that demonstrate value before someone becomes a member.
Acquisition
Onboarding that turns a new member’s expectation of value into experience of it.
Onboarding
Communications that keep the value of membership visible between renewals.
Engagement
Make value unmistakable when dues rise — 49% of associations raised them.
Renewal
Add value members will pay more for, lifting per-member worth over time.
Non-dues
Questions
Membership value has two sides. First, the value of a member to the organisation — their lifetime value, or the total revenue they generate across the years they stay, including dues and ancillary spend. Second, the value a member receives for their dues — the benefits, access, community and outcomes that make membership worth paying for. A healthy membership organisation manages both: it knows what members are worth and makes sure members feel they get their money’s worth.
Member lifetime value is roughly annual member value multiplied by average tenure. Tenure is 1 ÷ churn rate, so at the sector median 84% renewal (16% churn) the average member stays about six years. A member paying £175 a year who stays six years and spends a little on top is worth over £1,000 — many times the typical cost of acquiring them. Our lifetime value calculator works this out for your numbers.
Because members increasingly question it. In the MGI 2025 Membership Marketing Benchmarking Report, only 11% of associations described their value proposition as “very compelling”, yet 49% raised their dues. Charging more while value feels uncertain is how retention problems start. A clear, well-communicated value proposition is the foundation of both acquisition and renewal.
On the organisation side, increase lifetime value by improving retention and growing ancillary revenue per member. On the member side, sharpen and communicate the proposition: clarify the benefits that matter most, deliver them consistently, and reinforce them through content and onboarding so value is felt all year, not just at renewal. The two reinforce each other — members who feel more value stay longer and are worth more.
Two sides of membership value: what a member is worth, and the value they get.
Book a free consultation to sharpen your value proposition and grow member lifetime value.
Book Free Consultation